Roach says King James reigns as most talented

Share this story

Trainer Freddie Roach said that former protege James Toney, shown on left fighting Samuel Peter, is the most-talented fighter he's ever worked with. Photo / fightwireimages.com


Trainer Freddie Roach is working with the best fighter pound-for-pound in the world, at least in the opinion of most boxing experts.

So can we assume that Manny Pacquiao is also the most talented fighter he’s trained? No.

The most naturally gifted fighter ever to hit Roach’s mitts, he said, was James Toney, the former world champion in three weight classes who never had a worth ethic to match his God-given ability.

“Toney is the most natural fighter I’ve ever seen,” said Roach, who has been a trainer for almost 20 years. “When he says, ‘All you mother------- have to train but I was born to fight,’ he meant it. The way he moved, the vision he had, to see everything coming at him, he was just so gifted.

“He’s getting older now and getting hit more than ever. At one time, though, he’d sit on the ropes and make you miss 100 punches and come back with counter shots. It was something to watch.”

Toney just didn’t want to work and battled weight problems as a result, which saddens Roach.

“He had no discipline,” Roach said. “If he had discipline, he could’ve been heavyweight champion of the world and dominated the division. It just didn’t turn out that way. I’m not sure why he didn’t get in shape and stay healthy. I guess some guys with that kind of talent just take it for granted.

“Then, all of sudden, you realize it’s over.”

It’s not quite over for a still-competitive Toney, now 40. He faces Tony Thompson in a heavyweight bout on Dec. 12 in Cabazon, Calif.

More Roach: If Roach could build the perfect fighter from among those he trained, he would have the …

Boxing ability of Toney
Punching power of Mike Tyson
Jab of Virgil Hill
Defensive skills of Marlon Starling
Chin of Steve Collins
Work ethic of Pacquiao and Hill
Durability of Pacquiao

Share this story

On Sale Now

The Ring Magazine The Ring Magazine

- June Table of Contents

To Buy a Back Issue of The Ring Magazine, click on SUBSCRIBE at the Top of the Page.

Subscribe to the Ring >

Current Poll

What would the result be if Floyd Mayweather Jr. were to fight Manny Pacquiao? The results of this poll will be published in the August issue of THE RING Magazine.

The Rumor Mill

Williams' promoter: Alvarez a "welcome" challenge

Two-time welterweight beltholder Paul Williams is being considered for a bout with WBC junior middleweight titleholder Saul Alvarez in September.

Read More »

Ward-Dawson targeted for Sept. 8

THE RING's super middleweight and lt. heavyweight champs, Andre Ward and Chad Dawson, could fight on Sept. 8.

Read More »

Lara in search of new opponent

Junior middleweight Erislandy Lara is in search of an opponent for his WBC eliminator bout.

Read More »

Rapper 50 cent eyes a pro debut?

Rapper 50 Cent, part of Floyd Mayweather's "Money Team," says he is considering making his pro boxing debut.

Read More »

Marquez seeks southpaw opponent

Juan Manuel Marquez wants to fight a southpaw in July, with an eye toward a fourth bout with Manny Pacquiao.

Read More »

Read More Rumors News